Two things...
1) Stop quoting or mentioning things from the private details...this is an offense that can (and will) lead to suspensions and/or bans. Everyone read this again as a refresher (or for the first time):
https://ampreviews.net/index.php?threads/tips-on-maintaining-active-membership.13608/
2) Each member has the right to post THEIR own review, and does not need to justify himself to anyone. This is HIS review, and his account and experience...believe him, or don't believe him, but there's no need to call BS on it. If you don't agree, just move on. Or feel free to post your rebuttal on YOUR own review, and not disparage OP's. Any experienced member will know to take any and all reviews with a grain of salt, but by continuing to discuss the review, you're all needlessly bumping the thread up. If no one comments on it, it'll just eventually fade and get pushed more and more down.