AMP Reviews
  • You asked and we delivered! AMPReviews now provides the option to upgrade to VIP access via paid subscription as an alternative to writing your own reviews. VIP Access allows you to read all the hidden content within member-submitted reviews AND gives access to private VIP-only forums in each city. You can upgrade your account INSTANTLY by visiting the Account Upgrades page in your own user profile and using a valid credit card to purchase a subscription. You can get to this page by clicking the link in any review, by clicking the red "See the Details Now" banner on the home page, and by clicking the Purchase Private Details link in the navbar at the top of every page

Moderna or Pfizer or J&J?

Status
Not open for further replies.

njlefty

Registered Member
Messages: 2,418
Reviews: 5
Joined
#22
Just get the shots. Any of them. The goal is not to eliminate covid, but to limit the impact.
If anyone wants a private lesson on what the efficacy rates REALLY mean, and the real goal of this vaccine, please DM me, I would be happy to explain efficacy rates in relation to clinical trials.
I am curious as to your opinion of the efficacy of Moderna after one shot.

I have seen so many percentages tossed out that I have no clue as to what is accurate. Thanks.
 

Magiktung

Review Contributor
Messages: 411
Reviews: 35
Joined
#23
I am curious as to your opinion of the efficacy of Moderna after one shot.

I have seen so many percentages tossed out that I have no clue as to what is accurate. Thanks.
Single shot really depends on if you had covid previously. There are new studies in place now to see if single shot WITH cured covid is as effective.
 

njlefty

Registered Member
Messages: 2,418
Reviews: 5
Joined
#24
Single shot really depends on if you had covid previously. There are new studies in place now to see if single shot WITH cured covid is as effective.
Avoided getting Covid. Had the single shot on March 19. Second one will be April 16.

I have seen efficacy rates from 50 to 80 percent two weeks after first shot.
 

Cheyenne

Registered Member
Messages: 194
Reviews: 4
Joined
#25
Def some efficacy after first shot, second shot acts almost like a booster. Getting second Pfizer shot in two weeks. Just hanging low for the time being with the daily case load so freaking high, not really sure why it's so out of control. But will feel better after this second shot. Good luck to everyone and stay safe.
 

Magiktung

Review Contributor
Messages: 411
Reviews: 35
Joined
#26
Avoided getting Covid. Had the single shot on March 19. Second one will be April 16.

I have seen efficacy rates from 50 to 80 percent two weeks after first shot.
That’s about right. In the studies, ZERO people were hospitalized, experienced severe symptoms, or died with full doses of any of the vaccines. The vaccines do not 100% prevent disease. They do prevent death, severe symptoms, and hospitalization.

I’ll say it again ZERO.
 

yougen

Review Contributor
Messages: 838
Reviews: 45
Joined
#27
If I were given choice, I would go for Moderna. Here's my reasoning. I know all 3 are effective in preventing death or severe symptoms, but Moderna and Pfizer can effectively prevent even mild symptoms. Between the M & P, I lean slightly towards M, only because P requires such extreme low temperature for transport that any logistical error or negligence can render the vaccine ineffective and we wouldn't even know it.
 

Magiktung

Review Contributor
Messages: 411
Reviews: 35
Joined
#28
If I were given choice, I would go for Moderna. Here's my reasoning. I know all 3 are effective in preventing death or severe symptoms, but Moderna and Pfizer can effectively prevent even mild symptoms. Between the M & P, I lean slightly towards M, only because P requires such extreme low temperature for transport that any logistical error or negligence can render the vaccine ineffective and we wouldn't even know it.
Sound reasons. But ultimately we need as many people to get any vaccine. That will start to break the communicability chain and feel herd immunity.

We are on the right track.
 

njlefty

Registered Member
Messages: 2,418
Reviews: 5
Joined
#29
If I were given choice, I would go for Moderna. Here's my reasoning. I know all 3 are effective in preventing death or severe symptoms, but Moderna and Pfizer can effectively prevent even mild symptoms. Between the M & P, I lean slightly towards M, only because P requires such extreme low temperature for transport that any logistical error or negligence can render the vaccine ineffective and we wouldn't even know it.
This is something I had also been thinking about. I am glad I got any shot, though. Moderna was the one available to me.
 

cocolover81

Registered Member
Messages: 965
Reviews: 49
Joined
#30
It's crazy there's so much debate over the vaccines. TL;DR just take any one half pfizer/moderna to start, or the full J&J if you can get it.

The potency of ALL of the vaccines, whether it's Pfizer or Moderna or J&J are to prevent death and serious hospitalizations. They each achieve this 100% provided that you don't have health complications.

The efficacy rates are statistics obtained from trials on a sample amount of individuals regarding infections/reinfections and whatnot; this included placebos. P/M done theirs when cases were rising. J&J had done theirs at the peak of highest cases. They will have a lower efficacy rate because of the high amount of infections versus P/M trials.

The reason behind why Pfizer/Moderna are two shots versus J&J's single shot has to do with logistics. P/M already had a lot of vaccines going into production and wanted to get as many people half vaccinated as possible with what's at hand versus less people with the deadlines set by the government. More people with it at half > less people at full while cases go up in the states. J&J are late to the vaccine game, but they are doing one shot one deal so they don't need to split theirs.
 

Magiktung

Review Contributor
Messages: 411
Reviews: 35
Joined
#31
It's crazy there's so much debate over the vaccines. TL;DR just take any one half pfizer/moderna to start, or the full J&J if you can get it.

The potency of ALL of the vaccines, whether it's Pfizer or Moderna or J&J are to prevent death and serious hospitalizations. They each achieve this 100% provided that you don't have health complications.

The efficacy rates are statistics obtained from trials on a sample amount of individuals regarding infections/reinfections and whatnot; this included placebos. P/M done theirs when cases were rising. J&J had done theirs at the peak of highest cases. They will have a lower efficacy rate because of the high amount of infections versus P/M trials.

The reason behind why Pfizer/Moderna are two shots versus J&J's single shot has to do with logistics. P/M already had a lot of vaccines going into production and wanted to get as many people half vaccinated as possible with what's at hand versus less people with the deadlines set by the government. More people with it at half > less people at full while cases go up in the states. J&J are late to the vaccine game, but they are doing one shot one deal so they don't need to split theirs.
Perfectly said.
 

njlefty

Registered Member
Messages: 2,418
Reviews: 5
Joined
#33
It's crazy there's so much debate over the vaccines. TL;DR just take any one half pfizer/moderna to start, or the full J&J if you can get it.

The potency of ALL of the vaccines, whether it's Pfizer or Moderna or J&J are to prevent death and serious hospitalizations. They each achieve this 100% provided that you don't have health complications.

The efficacy rates are statistics obtained from trials on a sample amount of individuals regarding infections/reinfections and whatnot; this included placebos. P/M done theirs when cases were rising. J&J had done theirs at the peak of highest cases. They will have a lower efficacy rate because of the high amount of infections versus P/M trials.

The reason behind why Pfizer/Moderna are two shots versus J&J's single shot has to do with logistics. P/M already had a lot of vaccines going into production and wanted to get as many people half vaccinated as possible with what's at hand versus less people with the deadlines set by the government. More people with it at half > less people at full while cases go up in the states. J&J are late to the vaccine game, but they are doing one shot one deal so they don't need to split theirs.
I appreciate what you’re saying and I agree with you. I feel as if the one shot of Moderna currently in my system will prevent me from getting seriously sick, and I look forward to getting my second shot on April 16. With variants on the rise and more waves apparently heading our way, we’re in bad straits again unless people get their shots.
 

livinthedream

Registered Member
Messages: 618
Reviews: 35
Joined
#34
i got the moderna. first shot, just the sore arm. second shot hit me overnight. felt like i was getting the flu. arm hurt, every joint in my body hurts, chills.
the person who gave me the shot told me she had a terrible reaction to the pfizer one.
 

Spa1123

Review Contributor
Messages: 1,021
Reviews: 38
Joined
#35

Magiktung

Review Contributor
Messages: 411
Reviews: 35
Joined
#37

Cheyenne

Registered Member
Messages: 194
Reviews: 4
Joined
#40
those looking for the J&J shot, this is why you can't find it. Pretty big screw up

"The news that the contractor, Emergent BioSolutions, had ruined 15 million doses of Johnson & Johnson's vaccine by mistakenly mixing it with ingredients from another coronavirus shot became public on Wednesday"
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top