I’m looking for more independent pro.
I have done outcall all over the country, and prefer it. But I would never do an agency outcall unless I knew them well. Typically an indy I have screened well.
In the NYC area TER used to have some good options, but they are gone. Get onto P411 as soon as you can, but you will need two references from women.
ECCIE has some good ones, but NYC area isn't their best coverage.
Hopefully some on here will give you some links to places that cover NYC better.
One other thing: depending upon time available to you, and your mobility, you can often go to Toronto or Montreal when airfare is cheap, see a couple ladies there, get your P411 references--all for not much more than a good NYC outcall.