This has always been the eternal debate on this and other boards. Age vs. Service levels.
Some guys are age guys. They want a young gal. That is their thing and starts their motors up. Rod Steward, he would always trade in his model wife when she got into her 30's for another one in her early 20's. I know what they are talking about. A young gal has a certain energy to her that $200,000 of plastic surgery can never replicate.
Some guys are service guys and yes, experience does matter. You can't fake it if you're a younger gal. I remember a very funny comic talking about a politically charged, belief system that promises 20 virgins in paradise, he made a comment like, "do I have to talk to them? That would be hell". He said, paradise for him would be a few fire breathing whores.
I personally lean towards the experienced and service levels. The last time I was with a really younger gal, when I flipped over, she was acting really shy and had her arm over her small breasts as if she didn't want to show them to me. She started with the BS about wanting implants. Now I had to play shrink and start with the "Oh, no honey, let me see them. Oh their beautiful (and they were, putting implants into her body would of been a crime)". It is just kind of that vibe you get with a younger gal. I am not paying money to play shrink to some giggly inexperienced girl that doesn't want to spread her legs because she doesn't want me to think of her as a slut.
It kind of reminds me of an old ex-girlfriend. I was her 1st boyfriend after her divorce. I remember she made a comment to me about how, sex was different with me. She felt free, because something mentally switched for her. She was now a divorced woman, she no longer needed to play that "pure virgin good girl" role, in her mind. She said, before she didn't want her husband to think she was a bad girl. She said, she mentally had given herself permission to be slutty.
There is no right answers here. If you like a younger one, that is fine. If you like an experienced one that is also fine. As far as price and value, just keep this in mind when you write your reviews.