AMP Reviews
  • You asked and we delivered! AMPReviews now provides the option to upgrade to VIP access via paid subscription as an alternative to writing your own reviews. VIP Access allows you to read all the hidden content within member-submitted reviews AND gives access to private VIP-only forums in each city. You can upgrade your account INSTANTLY by visiting the Account Upgrades page in your own user profile and using a valid credit card to purchase a subscription. You can get to this page by clicking the link in any review, by clicking the red "See the Details Now" banner on the home page, and by clicking the Purchase Private Details link in the navbar at the top of every page

162nd st

Rombulous

Check It
Messages: 1,430
Reviews: 1
Joined
#21
Two exceptions. Hanwoo Beef and Jeju Black Pork. Still very very expensive. Most of my Korean friends agree at how cheap beef is here.
They can order Wagyu from Japan from smaller suppliers direct. It's about $100 to feed an extended family of 10 for 1 day which is not bad if you only eat beef once a week and it's 5 working adults and 5 kids. That's $20 per adult per week. Expensive on average Asian wages but on a U.S. wage it's about average.
 

krideynyc

Registered Member
Messages: 3,308
Reviews: 9
Joined
#22
They can order Wagyu from Japan from smaller suppliers direct. It's about $100 to feed an extended family of 10 for 1 day which is not bad if you only eat beef once a week and it's 5 working adults and 5 kids. That's $20 per adult per week.
That's actually the point. I can get Wagu in NYC. I can only get either Hanwoo beef or Jeju Black Pork in South Korea. Even though I'm paying Wagu prices for them there.
 

bronzeharbor

Review Contributor
Messages: 1,364
Reviews: 56
Joined
#29
Not to be an ass but Manhattan KBBQ is wack
You gotta hit up Flushing or Murray Hill for the more authentic KBBQ.
The new modern KBBQ spots cater to both a more diverse and younger crowd with their set menus and loud music. Some of the stuff they serve tastes like it came from the H Mart frozen aisle.
 

krideynyc

Registered Member
Messages: 3,308
Reviews: 9
Joined
#30
Not to be an ass but Manhattan KBBQ is wack
You gotta hit up Flushing or Murray Hill for the more authentic KBBQ.
I think it's that the Manhattan places have to cater to a wider clientele. But the ones in Flushing is fine if all they get are Korean customers. As you've said, some of the places needs you to bring a Korean friend.
 

HJguy

Registered Member
Messages: 255
Reviews: 5
Joined
#31
Not to be an ass but Manhattan KBBQ is wack
You gotta hit up Flushing or Murray Hill for the more authentic KBBQ.
The new modern KBBQ spots cater to both a more diverse and younger crowd with their set menus and loud music. Some of the stuff they serve tastes like it came from the H Mart frozen aisle.
I beg to differ on this, There is no way that Flusing offers authentic KBBQ. I tried couple places and gave up on them since the food was really nothing to write home about.
 

bronzeharbor

Review Contributor
Messages: 1,364
Reviews: 56
Joined
#33
Pork belly, beef brisket, and short rib are like the holy trinity of KBBQ. You can't be ordering pork belly at a short rib spot either.
Manhattan is full of your "dry aged" or "American wagyu" rubbish that simply doesn't belong in KBBQ.
 

krideynyc

Registered Member
Messages: 3,308
Reviews: 9
Joined
#34
There is no way that Flusing offers authentic KBBQ.
Let's make it easy. To me, and I think a few others, "authentic" means as similar to what you would find in Korea. So I agree with this statement:
Pork belly, beef brisket, and short rib are like the holy trinity of KBBQ. You can't be ordering pork belly at a short rib spot either.
The restaurants in Flushing closely matches the restaurants I've been to in Korea.

Can't wait to hear your choice for, not only more authentic, but higher quality, Korean BBQ in Manhattan.
 

Nyguy807

Review Contributor
Messages: 209
Reviews: 40
Joined
#36
Let's make it easy. To me, and I think a few others, "authentic" means as similar to what you would find in Korea. So I agree with this statement:
The restaurants in Flushing closely matches the restaurants I've been to in Korea.

Can't wait to hear your choice for, not only more authentic, but higher quality, Korean BBQ in Manhattan.
KBBQ isn’t authentic in Korea. Beef wasn’t readily available there. KBBQ has roots in the states, mainly LA in the 80s. I should know. My family was in the business and KBBQ families were closely knit back then when there were only a few of us.
 

krideynyc

Registered Member
Messages: 3,308
Reviews: 9
Joined
#37
KBBQ isn’t authentic in Korea. Beef wasn’t readily available there. KBBQ has roots in the states, mainly LA in the 80s. I should know. My family was in the business and KBBQ families were closely knit back then when there were only a few of us.
It's a bastard cuisine that's based on the Mongolian BBQ found in US Army bases. Started in the 1950's in Taiwan. I have one of the original brass BBQ pots used in the NCO Mess Halls. It came into it's own form in the 1970's.
 

Nyguy807

Review Contributor
Messages: 209
Reviews: 40
Joined
#40
KBBQ doesn't refer to just the meat itself.
It's a dining experience all on its own.
That's what most are talking about when talking about "authentic"
That’s just Korean food in general. It’s how we eat regardless if it’s at a restaurant or at home. Main dish(es) with a bunch of banchan
 
Top